Monday, November 21, 2011

Spanish election results confirm “Catalonia is not Spain”

El Punt Avui - Catalonia is not SpainThe Catalan language newspaper, El Punt Avui proclaims in English that “Catalonia is not Spain” this morning, in an attempt at explaining how the Catalan conservative party CiU managed to stem the blue tide of the rightist Spanish Popular Party that swept through most of the rest of Spain. The slogan in English, usually used by protesters at international events to bring attention to the ongoing struggle for more autonomy in Catalonia, neatly sums up the election results: the rightist Partido Popular swept the ruling PSOE party out of office in a stunning defeat, but were unable to make inroads in Catalonia, where the Catalanist though perhaps equally conservative CiU party took the region for the first time ever in general Spanish elections.

Spanish Election ResultsWhat the slogan doesn't explain to outsiders is why Catalonia is so different, and how the PP could have had such lackluster results there while sweeping every other part of Spain except the Basque Country, as shown in the map to the right.

The answer is that elections in Catalonia, especially “general elections” in which the seats in the Spanish Parliament are chosen, have various axes, not only right vs left, but Catalanist vs Spainist, for want of better terms. The important leftist parties in Spain have local affiliates in Catalonia that are mostly seen as hewing to the centralist party line. They tend to win country-wide elections and lose local ones. The right in Catalonia, however, is divided between the local affiliate of the Spanish Popular Party—whose francoist roots make it a particularly hard sell in Catalonia—and the completely homegrown CiU, whose wildly popular leader, Jordi Pujol was president of the Catalan Parliament for 23 years between 1980 and 2003, and with these results completed the trifecta after already having triumphed in recent municipal and Catalonia-wide elections.

It seems unsurprising that Catalans would want to kick the Socialists out, but would choose to do so without running into the arms of the PP, whose party was behind the recent trampling of Catalonia's new Statute of Autonomy, as well as attacks on the successful and popular Catalan-immersive educational system.

CiU clenched the deal with a big promise: they will demand a “fiscal pact” with Madrid, and if rebuffed, will demand political independence. Catalonia currently pays some 10% more in taxes than they receive in services from the central government, and the current fiscal crisis is fueling resentment in Catalonia. Catalans see brand new schools, free highways, and high speed trains in sparsely populated areas of Spain while being forced to make substantial cuts in medical, educational, and transportation services of their own.

As Salvador Cardús put it in What Catalans Want, “We live in a situation in which we are denied the guarantee that our daily work will contribute in any way to our prosperity.”

It's important to remember that Duran i Lleida, CiU's candidate, is more unionist than separatist, despite convenient rhetoric to the contrary. Last night he said, “Catalonia is different from the rest of the country. Today, these results confirm more than ever that we are a nation.”

It will be interesting to watch these next few months.


  1. I think the title to your post and that of El Punt's article, are extremely biased and not fair to the results.

    The increase in number of votes to CiU (29% from 2008's 21%) is indeed impressive. CiU has never, however, defined itself as separatist (i.e. Catalunya not being Spain) and has been the strongest opposition party in Catalunya's Parliament for the last 8 years, just like PP was during the same time in most other Spanish regions'.

    On top of that, in these elections, the amount of Catalan people that changed their previous votes and gave it to separatists that do claim that Catalunya is not Spain (that admittedly did increased in votes, from 8% in 2008 to 9%), was immensely smaller than those that gave it to PP, with its admittedly seemingly hard-to-sell "francoist roots" and "attacks on Catalan-immersive educational system" (from 16% in 2008 to a whooping 21%). You cannot honestly say CiU's 29% is extraordinary and then qualify PP's 21% as lackluster and not some "inroads", whatever your political views on the matter are. What is the separatists' mere 1% increase after PP spent 8 years in the opposition using Catalunya as an easy target to wear down Spain's government without the need to compromise on statements in order to govern?

    My opinion is that what can only be read is that people punished the party in the central government, and pivoted towards what people perceive is the strongest local opposition party, just like elsewhere (in Catalunya that one was CiU until a few months ago —hence, still perceived as an alternative—, in the rest of Spain in almost all cases was PP). Simple as that. There is no sign whatsoever that any supposed resurgence in Catalans national aspirations is happening and that it had anything to do in these elections. If anything, in a time where people care more about their pocket than their identity, I would say the opposite.

  2. You hit the nail !

  3. Sorry for the first commentary but i vote convergencia i unio and like the majority of the people who support this coalition of parties i am for the independence of catalonia...


More of my books